Addressing Attacks on Human Rights Defenders & Independent Media: How Can Cross-Border Solidarity Help?
Printer-friendly versionSend to friendThe Sixth Assembly
The Sixth Assembly
Solidarity Across Cultures
Addressing Attacks on Human Rights Defenders & Independent Media: How Can Cross-Border Solidarity Help?
Organizer:
Moderator:
Hassan Shire Sheikh – East and Horn of Africa Human Rights Defenders Network (Somalia)
Rapporteur:
Rose Nyawira – Pamoja Trust (Kenya)
Presenters:
Adilur Khan – Odhikar (Bangladesh)
Floribert Chebeya Bahizire – La Voix Des Sans Voix (Democratic Republic of Congo)
Emin Huseynov – Institute for Reporters Freedom and Safety (Azerbaijan)
The workshop presenters focused in their presentations on their own experiences working as human rights defenders, as well as on the overall human rights situations in their countries, and they described their governments’ strategies to curb freedoms of speech, participation, and information. The ensuing discussion also focused on the common threat of torture and persecution.
The discussion highlighted the efforts of civil society organizations (CSOs) to address the safety and protection of human rights defenders, in addition to disseminating information and promoting solidarity networks around the world. CSOs provide resources to individuals, including relocation to a different country, especially if a defender’s life is at risk; training in the security of defenders; the organization of conferences and fora in which activists can discuss their challenges and achievements; and facilitation in the use of the Internet and audio-visual media for communication and information sharing to build relationships of solidarity. To some extent, such initiatives have been successful. In Poland, for instance, CSOs train journalists and students in documenting and reporting on human rights violations using community radio.
By reporting on their own situations and human rights violations, activistshave indirectly supported human rights defenders in neighboring countries. There are also organizations that promote the use of conferences and Web sites to share information. Witness, a nongovernmental organization based in Europe, provides equipment, training, and video hubs. These are opportunities we could tap, among others, to ensure that defender issues are discussed in the global arena.
In countries run by dictatorial and military regimes, human rights defenders are always at high risk of being tortured and persecuted. In the case of Somalia and Azerbaijan, where the media is controlled by the government, many human rights defenders are tracked down, carefully monitored, and, in some cases, executed. In these circumstances, the media serves as an instrument of propaganda by the government.
How human rights defenders in Belarus have dealt with media restrictions provides a compelling example of the need for solidarity. Solidarity can also work well in Asia and Africa, since there are some common languages in these regions. Ultimately, there is a need to invest more resources into building solidarity, especially since human rights defenders are critical for the wider fight for justice and democracy.
All the presenters shared similar stories of governmental suppression mechanisms and the challenges faced by defenders. They also therefore called on CSOs to work together and to develop networks to address those challenges. In particular, they noted that young, emerging activists should be supported.
Participants in the workshop agreed that human rights defenders can benefit from innovative ways of communicating with each other about the lessons they've learned about how best to protect themselves. Specifically, they can learn from the innovative strategies of youth and from professionals in public relations and communications. Moreover, youth activists, journalists, and human rights practitioners can all benefit by sharing their expertise with each other.
Challenges
The challenges facing human rights defenders are diverse and vary according to local contexts. In the discussion, these challenges were viewed within the framework of access to media, working in armed conflicts, and political oppression. Some of the challenges that human rights defenders face include:
- Harassment and intimidation;
- Defamation;
- Legal proceedings to drain human rights defenders of resources, time, etc.;
- Arbitrary arrests and detention;
- Targeted killings;
- Disappearances;
- Legal restrictions, such as national laws that criminalize the activities of human rights defenders (e.g., sexual minority rights defenders under the Civil Society Proclamation in Ethiopia);
- Governments’ persistent failure to comply with treaty obligations under international law;
- Increased insecurity in many countries;
- Insufficient financial resources to carry out planned activities; and
- Insufficient networking among human rights organizations.
Recommendations
- Promote the capacity of human rights defenders to carry out audio-visual reporting and monitoring (use of video, films, and documentaries).
- Start a campaign to promote the Internet as a means to communicate and to organize for democracy work, particularly since it is becoming one of the main methods of sharing information quickly, especially among youth.
- Dedicate a person to work directly and specifically with journalists and activists to address their challenges at the regional level and in EU countries.
- Groups should share most of their information with diaspora groups so that together they can push for better human rights situations.
- Use UN information on how presidents vote on issues in international bodies and use it as a basis to organize for accountability.
- Lobby more donors to support human rights protection initiatives.
- Create a global human rights network.
- Call on public relations and communication experts "without borders" so they can offer their skills and knowledge to support human rights defenders.
- Develop a standard template to organize national and international campaigns in support of prosecuted human rights defenders.
- Give greater support to enable the escape and departure from a country because most defenders do not necessarily have contacts within their neighboring countries and thus can sometimes become stranded. There is also a need to support defenders getting situated in a new country since their governments are often able to follow them when they leave.
- Promote a culture of tolerance and solidarity through trainings and conferences. Ensure that mechanisms exist for information from such activities to reach the grassroots.
- Create mechanisms for the legal protection of defenders at all levels and for their safety during trials, especially at the International Court.
- Promote education and mentoring in schools and other learning institutions, and call upon journalists to cultivate innovative and new technologies for helping prevent human rights abuses.
- Promote youth innovation in reporting, monitoring, and campaigns for human rights.

.jpg)